Coroner’s Inquest: Sequence of Testimony

By clicking on the name of a particular witness you can be taken to a complete transcript of that witness’s original inquest, as recorded at the time the statements were given.

 

Date Proceeding Character Result/Notes
10/28/1881 Coroners Inquest
Day 1 Johnny Behan Changed story, from Nugget newspaper statement, to make Virgil look bad; also started the “nickel-plated pistol” theory against Doc
Billy Claiborne Supported Behans story; added that Virgil was first to make statement of wanting to fight
W.A. Smith Sworn and excused; no testimony given
W.A. Cuddy Gives good account of before and after fight; recollects Wyatt telling Behan that he was told they had been disarmed
Billy Claiborne Recalled for a clarification
C.H. Light Witnessed fight from across the street; gave account of almost complete fight
 

 

10/29/1881 Coroners Inquest
Day 2 P.H. Fellehy Claimed to hear Virgil say he would “kill them on sight”; was never called to testify during trial
Ike Clanton Supported Behan’s story, specifically the “nickel plated pistol” theory; didn’t mention deal with Earps as he would do in the upcoming trial
Martha King Claimed to hear Doc Holliday being told to “let them have it” while carrying a shotgun under his coat; could not clarify if it was a stand-alone statement, or part of a conditional
R.J. Coleman Had tracked cow-boy movements and reported them to the law; believed firing began as result of command to throw up their hands

Leave a comment

Making some sense of the old west